Choosing an advisor

Business Broker vs M&A Advisor vs Commercial Real Estate Broker: Who Should Sell Your Business?

When you start looking for help selling your company, three kinds of professionals will tell you they can do it: commercial real estate brokers, business brokers and M&A advisors. They often present themselves as interchangeable. They aren't, and the choice affects who sees your business, how many buyers compete for it, and what you keep.

By Simon Fallows, Founder, Freedom For Founders
Updated September 20267 min read
Quick answer

A commercial real estate broker specializes in property. A business broker and an M&A advisor both sell operating businesses, and in practice most M&A advisors are business brokers under a different title. The title matters less than what the person commits to. If your sale doesn't include commercial property, look for a broker or advisor who takes the time to understand your business, markets it to targeted buyers on your terms, and creates competition between them.

On this page
  1. What is the difference between the three?
  2. Is a commercial real estate broker the same as a business broker?
  3. Does it matter if your sale includes property?
  4. Are business brokers and M&A advisors different?
  5. What is "post and pray," and why does it cost you?
  6. Should you sell to a strategic or a financial buyer?
  7. What should a broker or advisor commit to?
  8. What are the red flags?
  9. How is Freedom For Founders different?
  10. Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the three?

Short answer

Commercial real estate brokers value and sell property. Business brokers and M&A advisors value and sell companies, based on earnings, customers, team and how well the business transfers to a new owner. The two skill sets overlap far less than most owners assume.

Commercial real estate brokerBusiness brokerM&A advisor
What they know bestBuildings, land, leases, locationOperating businessesOperating businesses
How value is setRents, location, comparable property salesNormalized earnings and buyer demandNormalized earnings and buyer demand
How buyers are foundProperty listings and investor networksListings, networks, targeted outreachNetworks and targeted outreach
Regulated in OntarioYes, RECO registrationYes, when property or a lease is part of the dealTitle isn't regulated, but the same rules apply to the same work
Best fitThe sale includes the buildingSelling the businessSelling the business

Is a commercial real estate broker the same as a business broker?

Short answer

No. A building is valued on location, rent and comparable property sales. A business is valued on how much it earns, how dependable those earnings are, and whether they will continue after you leave. Selling one well doesn't mean you can sell the other well.

Some commercial real estate brokers list businesses the same way they list buildings: a description, an asking price and a posting. That works for property. For a business, it skips most of what drives the price.

Does it matter if your sale includes property?

Short answer

Yes. If the building is part of the sale, you need a registered real estate professional to handle that part, and good advisors work alongside one. If the property isn't part of the sale, a real estate licence tells you little about someone's ability to sell your business.

In Ontario, representing a seller where real property or a commercial lease is involved falls under the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, and the person and firm must be registered with the Real Estate Council of Ontario (RECO). Many business sales include the assignment of a lease, so ask any firm how it handles that part of your deal.

Are business brokers and M&A advisors different?

Short answer

Mostly in name. Both sell operating businesses, and most M&A advisors are brokers by function. What separates a good one from a poor one is their process and what they commit to in writing, not their title.

Some firms calling themselves brokers run careful, confidential, targeted processes. Some calling themselves M&A advisors post a listing and wait. Judge the work, not the label.

What is "post and pray," and why does it cost you?

Short answer

Post and pray means listing a business on marketplaces and waiting for buyers to call. It is cheap to run but expensive for the seller: it attracts browsers, risks confidentiality, eats your time, and rarely reaches the strategic buyers most likely to pay a premium.

The costs show up in several ways:

  • The wrong buyers.Listings draw many inquiries from people who can't finance a deal or don't fit your business.
  • Confidentiality risk.The more public the listing, the more likely staff, customers or competitors recognize it.
  • Your time.Every unqualified inquiry pulls you away from running the business, and performance slipping during a sale lowers the price.
  • One buyer at a time.Without a planned process, offers arrive one by one and you lose the leverage competition gives you.
  • Missing the best buyers.Strategic buyers, such as competitors or companies in related markets, rarely browse listings. They have to be approached.

Should you sell to a strategic or a financial buyer?

Short answer

It depends on what your business offers and what you want after the sale. Strategic buyers may pay more because your business adds to theirs. Financial buyers, such as private equity, focus on cash flow and often want you or your team to stay. A good advisor identifies which buyers fit before marketing begins.

Strategic buyerFinancial buyer
Who they areCompetitors, suppliers, customers, companies in related marketsPrivate equity, family offices, individual investors
Why they buyCustomers, territory, capacity, capabilitiesCash flow and growth potential
What they may payOften more, if your business adds to theirsBased on earnings and financing
What happens to your teamMay be combined with theirsUsually kept in place
Your role afterOften shorter transitionOften asked to stay longer, sometimes with equity

Knowing your likely buyer shapes everything else: how the business is presented, which buyers get approached first, and which terms you negotiate hardest.

What should a broker or advisor commit to?

Short answer

Before marketing anything, they should learn your business and your goals. Then they should commit in writing to a marketing plan, a targeted buyer list, confidentiality steps, competing offers before exclusivity, regular reporting, and clear fees.

Ask for these commitments:

  • Understanding first.Time spent learning your financials, customers, team and goals before a teaser is written.
  • Your terms.Agreement on what matters to you: price, timing, your role after, and what happens to your staff.
  • A written marketing plan with a buyer list that includes strategic and financial buyers.
  • Confidentiality steps: anonymous teaser, NDA before details, staged release of information.
  • Competing offers.Expressions of Interest from several buyers before you sign an exclusive letter of intent.
  • Reporting.Who has been approached, who responded and what they said, on a set schedule.
  • Who does the work.The person running your file, named.
  • Clear fees, including how earn-outs, vendor financing and any "tail" after the agreement ends are treated.

What are the red flags?

Short answer

Be cautious of anyone who prices your business before learning it, wants to list immediately, relies mainly on public postings, brings one buyer at a time, or asks for a long exclusive agreement with no performance commitments.

  • No clear answer on registration where property or a lease is involved
  • A valuation that seems designed to win your business rather than hold up with buyers
  • No plan for reaching strategic buyers
  • No interest in your tax position or the Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption
  • Vague answers about who does the work

How is Freedom For Founders different?

Short answer

Freedom For Founders is a Canadian M&A advisory and exit planning firm. We learn your business and your goals first, then market it to targeted buyers on your terms. Our approach is freedom first, strategy second, sale last.

For the full sale process, see How to Sell a Business in Canada: The 12-Month Playbook.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a business broker and an M&A advisor?

In practice, very little. Both sell operating businesses, and most M&A advisors are business brokers under a different title. What matters is their process: whether they learn your business, market it to targeted buyers, protect confidentiality and create competition before you sign an exclusive deal.

Can a commercial real estate broker sell my business?

A commercial real estate broker specializes in property, which is valued differently from a business. If your sale includes the building, a registered real estate professional should handle that part. For the business itself, look for someone experienced in selling operating companies.

What is post and pray in business sales?

Post and pray means listing a business on marketplaces and waiting for buyers to respond. It often attracts unqualified buyers, risks confidentiality and rarely reaches strategic buyers, who usually need to be approached directly.

What is the difference between a strategic and a financial buyer?

A strategic buyer is a company that gains from combining your business with theirs, such as a competitor or supplier, and may pay more for that reason. A financial buyer, such as private equity, buys mainly for cash flow and often keeps the existing team in place.

How do I choose someone to sell my business?

Choose someone who learns your business before marketing it, commits in writing to a targeted buyer list and marketing plan, collects competing offers before exclusivity, reports regularly and explains fees clearly. Speak to two sellers they have worked with.

Sellability Score

Where should you start?

Before choosing who helps you sell, find out where your business stands. Take the free Sellability Score to see your strengths and risks through a buyer's eyes. It takes about 13 minutes.

Free. About 13 minutes. Private & confidential.